Monthly Brief 3 : ESG Factors in Sovereign Ratings

This is the third in the series of briefs published ahead of the launch, this November, of the AfDB Sovereign Credit Rating

Initiative, implemented by the ALSF. Brief 1 considered the role of credit rating agencies in Africa, while Brief 2 examined

the importance of effective sovereign investor relations. This brief turns to another increasingly visible feature of

sovereign credit analysis: environmental, social and governance (“ESG”) factors.

The first point is one of definition. Credit rating agencies do not generally ask whether a sovereign is “good” on ESG in

the abstract. Their concern is narrower: whether an environmental, social or governance consideration is sufficiently

material to affect the sovereign’s capacity or willingness to service its debt. S&P Global Ratings, for example,

incorporates ESG factors where it considers them material to creditworthiness and sufficiently visible; Fitch similarly

considers ESG issues where they are credit-relevant and material to the rating decision. Moody’s likewise incorporates

ESG considerations into its credit analysis, using Issuer Profile Scores and Credit Impact Scores to assess their relevance

and credit impact, while making clear that these measures are distinct from the credit rating itself and do not constitute

separate ESG ratings.

Leave A Comment